• Free Initial Assessment: No-Obligation Chat

What are defined benefit pensions?

Defined Benefit Pension Guide

One of the most common types of retirement plans is defined benefit pensions. These pensions promise a guaranteed income for life and an assurance of financial stability, which many people want.

Where retirement income depends on investment performance, defined benefit pensions provide a fixed payout, giving retirees peace of mind knowing what they will receive monthly.

This blog post will examine defined benefit pensions—their pros and cons, and some examples—so you can better understand them and make the best financial decisions for your future.

This guide covers:

What is a defined benefit pension?

A defined benefit pension scheme is a pension scheme in which the amount you receive when you retire depends on how long you’ve worked for the company and your salary when you leave or retire.

How are defined benefit pensions paid?

As you work and contribute to your defined benefit pension, you accrue certain benefits based on a formula that considers your salary and length of service with the employer.

For example, it could be 1.5% of your average salary over the last five years of employment multiplied by the number of years you’ve worked.

A defined benefit pension is often paid monthly, where you receive a fixed amount each month for the rest of your life.

However, some plans offer the option of taking a one-time lump sum payment from the total pension pot. This is called Commutation (GOV.UK).

What is commutation?

Commutation involves exchanging future monthly pension payments for an immediate lump sum. This is often available as part of Defined Benefit Pensions, providing flexibility in how retirees can access their pension pot.

Why consider commutation on your pension?

There are three major reasons why you might consider commuting your pension payments.

1. Access your pension funds immediately

A large lump sum can be helpful if you want to write off major expenses like:

  • A mortgage
  • Home renovation costs
  • Debts

It’s also helpful if you need to support other family members financially or if your life expectancy after retirement is low and you want access to more of your money at once.

2. Flexibility in financial planning

Commutation also allows you to tailor your retirement income to suit your needs better if you want to:

  • Invest in opportunities that may yield higher returns
  • Create a financial cushion for any unexpected expenses
  • Achieve a specific financial goal, such as funding a family member’s business start-up or child’s education.

What are the advantages of a defined benefit pension?

For many, defined benefit pensions mean security and reliability in retirement planning. They offer a range of benefits that promise financial peace of mind from the moment you retire until the end of your life.

1. Guaranteed benefit until death

One of the standout features of defined benefit pensions is the guarantee of a secure income for as long as you live. This means you can count on receiving a regular payment instead of relying on other retirement savings that might run out over time.

This benefit until death removes the worry about outliving your savings so you can live without constant financial concern.

2. Protection against market fluctuations

Unlike defined contribution schemes, where retirement savings are subject to market performance’s highs and lows, defined benefit pensions offer protection against these uncertainties.

This secure income is reassuring for those who prefer not to make complex investment decisions that come with inherent risk.

3. Simplified retirement planning

Defined benefit pensions simplify retirement planning. With a clear understanding of your annual income and the knowledge of a secure income for life, you can focus more on enjoying your retirement and less on managing your money.

What are the disadvantages of a defined benefit pension?

While defined-benefit pensions offer a secure path to retirement for many, they also come with certain limitations and challenges that are important to keep in mind. These pension schemes may only fit some people’s needs or circumstances.

Let’s take a look at some of the disadvantages of defined-benefit pensions.

1. Inheritance limitations

Defined benefit pensions often have stricter rules regarding the inheritance of pension savings. Unlike defined contribution workplace pensions, where the remaining pension fund can often be passed on to beneficiaries, defined benefit schemes usually offer limited options for leaving a pension to loved ones.

2. Dependency on employer’s financial health

The security of a defined benefit pension is closely tied to the financial health of the employer or the pension fund.

While many countries, like the UK, have safeguards, such as pension protection schemes, the possibility of a fund encountering financial difficulties cannot be entirely ruled out.

3. Fixed retirement age

Defined benefit pensions typically set a fixed retirement age, which might not align with everyone’s career or life plans. If you want to retire earlier, accessing pension savings might come with penalties or reduced benefits.

Speak to the experts at Spencer Churchill Claims Advice

Have you been mis-sold on your pension, or need compensation for bad pension advice? Getting your hard-earned money can be tough, but it doesn’t have to be with Spencer Churchill Claims Advice

Our team of specialist <a “Mis Sold Financial Claims Solicitors” href=”/”>financial claims solicitors is dedicated to offering legal advice and support for mis-sold pension claims across the UK.

Don’t let uncertainty about past decisions affect your peace of mind. Get in touch now for an in-depth review of your pension claim today.

Ashley Chaplin
12 June 2024
Share this post:
No Upfront Fees

Let’s Rewrite Your Financial Story

We are here to rewrite the book for you. 
And luckily we are pretty damn good at creating happy endings.

Money Hands

We are here to rewrite the book for you. And luckily we are pretty damn good at creating happy endings.


When you get let down by someone you thought you could trust, it can leave its mark on you, emotionally and physically.


We are committed to transparency and fairness in the way we conduct with clients, including how we charge for our claims services.

Speak to an expert today

We have decades of experience in helping people claim back money that is rightfully theirs. Whether you want to make a mis-sold pension claim, have questions about a mis-sold investment, or you’re just looking for some advice you can trust – we’ve got you covered. Reach out to our team today for a no-obligation, completely free chat. 

Call: 01204929929

Office Hours:

Monday: 8:00am–6:00pm
Tuesday: 8:00am–6.00pm
Wednesday: 8:00am–6:00pm
Thursday: 8.00am–6.00pm
Friday: Office Closed

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.